How about this - I fired it up with the push rod back in (but still well loose) but due to time limitations I could only run it for a couple of min's......guess what.....it didn't pump up

See, when I think back to to the first time I heard this rattle, it was noisy but it still ran on all 8 - like the lifter wasn't pumping up for some reason. Then, at some point during diagnosis/driving it the push rod must have popped out....but it can't/shouldn't, right?
So possibly I've got a lifter that wont pump up and a push rod that's too short?
Could the valve be stuck open a bit maybe
