Bob,
Its a regular Mopar Oil pump drive, their about $90 bucks from Summit, in stock, as looked at ordering one this weekend.
When I asked, did it shear at the transition to allen drive, you said No ? So was confused to see the picture.
Like I said, I cant think if I used a longer gear drive or not, long time ago now, just recall the shaft being short for the KB Oil pump I was running ?
Which is why I said, check that shaft & pump are not bottoming out, when tightening the pump.
Easy to check, measure depth in pump & measure how much of shaft protrudes.As yours is broken, you will have to try & measure what you have (Depth mic) plus the broken part.
Your more than welcome to come & check out the bag of oil pump springs I have. I got these,as I had the same problem with too much oil pressure, so reduce the spring pressure in the oil pump.
For your information, I used a belt driven dizzy, so only used the shaft to drive the oil pump & not the dizzy. I modified an old dizzy housing to keep the oil shaft in the downward position to drive the oil pump.
How much pressure/torque was required on the pump, when you used a drill to prime the oil ?
I assume you were running the drill in reverse or no one ran the pump the wrong way when trying to prime ?
Cheers Mark (Yes, I stole Jerry's Password again

)