You are talking about a quarter inch difference in stroke length. 0.27-inch.
You really think a quarter inch is going to make one engine a low rpm tractor engine and the other a screaming F1 engine?
I think you are just over complicating and over thinking the whole thing. As well as listening to "old wives tales".
When i was a lad all the UK car magazines used to describe American V8 engines as "big lazy American V8s" because they were all seen as low rpm torque monsters.
For 20 years at least everyone (including American racers) were calling the 400 inch B-Block a usless "smog motor" not good for anything. When in fact it is actually the best engine of the lot!
All the Mopar V8s are well designed and very versitile engines. The only factors you have to think about are parts availability and intended power level. Obviously bigger and lighter is better. But you can make any of these engines fit that profile.
